September 5, 2011

Aiming With a Mouse… Old Habits Die Hard

I’m one of those, a PC Gamer and when I can purchase a title (outside of sports and racing games) on the PC platform I do.  Having said that, I realize the industry as a whole has shifted to console as a primary development platform.  While I much prefer gaming on a PC I do own all the major gaming consoles (Wii, PS3, XBox 360) and own a good number of titles on each of the systems.   Most of my friends also play on console systems and as such a few years ago I branched out to play games that I traditionally would only play on PC such as FPS and RTS.

Growing up (I’m 26 by the way) the PC was the dominant platform when it came to multiplayer gaming online and industry standard.  It was also the leader in graphics, performance and modding.  The console phenomenom has taken away the majority of what made PC gaming great during the late 90’s and early 2000’s, pushing the limits of hardware, user created content and online communities.  These are all things that have taken a backseat with the current generations of gamers. 

For the most part, I have come to terms with this however there is one thing that I simply cannot put my mind around and that is using a controller instead of a keyboard and mouse for gaming.  This is especially true for FPS and RTS titles that seem to be flooding the console market.   I’ve had a the latest and greatest consoles back to the regular nintendo days and I have tried, really tried, to get my mind and fingers around the concept of aiming with a joystick instead of using a mouse and keyboard.  I actually took the time one day to calculate how long it took me to aim for a headshot on a standstill target on a console vs a mouse and the difference was staggering.  It took me at times, to get a precision shot almost 2 – 3 seconds (yes I had my wife time me) with the controller to less then a seconds on the same title on the PC (I used Mass Effect 2). 

I have noticed that on consoles the aiming mechanics are a lot less percise.  For example on Halo 3, with the battle rifle, you could swing the gun from left to right on the screen and as long as you passed over your opponents head you would get a headshot regardless of wheather or not you actually fired the shot accuretly or not.  I’ve also noticed with popular console titles like Call of Duty: Black Ops that I could litterly shoot to the side of my opponent and score a headshot. 

I noticed when I play on consoles I cannot seperate three of my fingers at a time.  Basically this means  that I can either move and fire, aim and fire, move and aim.  I can’t do all three at one time.  Perhaps this is what it is like to learn how to play the drums.  I also cannot wrap my mind around using a joystick to get a precision shot. 

Some might say that I am stuck in the past, learn how to play, or just give up gaming.  I think in my case old habits just die hard.  I suspect that I will never fully be able to compete on console systems, most definately not at the CAL and tournament level I used to be when I played Counter-Strike back in the late 90’s and early 2000’s.

Does anyone else feel the same way?  Does anyone actually find it easier to aim with a controller instead of a mouse?  Let us know your story!

7 comments

  1. Pingback: WellTree | Blog | Cela est important

  2. ScrotusKilmystr - September 8, 2011 9:14 am

    back in the day I couldn’t imagine playing a console game now….I just haven’t gotten my flow back to play on the PC again damn console and your convenience…. I’m slowly trying to get my groove back om the PC however so maybe some day haha

    Reply
  3. Selonari - September 7, 2011 3:52 am

    PC gaming all the way. ESPECIALLY for shooters.

    Reply
  4. CABXYZ - September 6, 2011 4:58 pm

    All through college I had no issues switching back and forth. I either had and Xbox or GameCube with me and endless nights of Counter-Strike on the PC. Now I tried playing Counter-Strike Source and TF2 and I can not use a mouse anymore. I even tried doing the unimaginable and plugged a wired 360 pad into my PC for Counter-Strike. I think in a console driven era I am accustomed to the twin stick layout that a mouse and keyboard are second banana, even though they are more precise.

    Reply
  5. Pingback: Aiming With a Mouse… Old Habits Die Hard | The Gamers Blog | irydopefy

  6. CharcoalCoyote - September 6, 2011 9:25 am

    I’m one of those dual-type, all-around-if-it’s-good gamers. I was raised on consoles (my dad already owned a Super Nintendo and our computer had 16 gigs of hard drive space), but I eventually found my way to PC gaming for the whole “online” experience (which was exactly half a year before Halo 2 came out.) My first real FPS was Halo (Surprisingly, I had an N64 but didn’t have Goldeneye), and I quickly got involved with the custom mapping community. For roughly a year, Halo PC and Custom Edition was the ONLY game I played. Though I was more of a custom/machinima guy, I could easily hold my own in any team or 1v1 arena play. Point being, I got pretty damn good with the mouse.

    However, my best friends and fellow machinimakers were anxious to migrate to the new technology, so I got an Xbox 360 when they came out and jumped late onto the Halo 2 wagon. The games were different enough that by the time I had the hang of the new Battle Rifle and SMG(s), I already had a firm grasp on the joystick controls. Through the ins, outs, ons, and offs, I stuck by the Halo series and still occasionally play to this day.

    I’ve played almost every popular shooter with an incarnation on all platforms (Halo, Call of Duty, Battlefield), and the verdict is different for each game. Halo was always a console shooter, and while I feel that Halo PC was probably the best in the series, I’ve got to say that it handles better with the joysticks. I have a long and rough history with CoD as well, and the fact that they’re so heavily consolized now means that, while I prefer playing them on PC, they “feel” better on a controller. Battlefield is a PC game. Bad Company 1 and 2 were pretty good on console, but they feel a million times better on PC (though if you don’t have a joystick, flying the helicopters with the consoles was a lot easier than flying with a damn mouse.)

    The difference between mouse and controller shootering/gaming is just the practice. It takes a while to switch over, even if you’re well versed in both. I played the mousiest, PC-iest shooter of all time (Counter Strike) for about a year, and when I went back to Halo, everything was different. In all actuality, if you give me a month to adjust to either control scheme, I’ll probably play better with an Xbox 360 controller than a mouse and keyboard.

    On a completely unrelated note, though I’m fairly sure I know who wrote this, I can’t seem to see the author listed anywhere on this page. We might wanna fix that.

    Reply
  7. zero_19 - September 6, 2011 8:08 am

    I can’t aim for shit with a joystick. I’m a mouse gamer all the way.

    Reply

Have your say

Archives - Powered by WordPress - A theme by cssigniter.com